Six types of breathing meditation
Part of a series of teachings on A Presentation of the Establishment of Mindfulness by Gyalwa Chokyi Gyaltsen.
- Breathing meditation as preparatory practice for establishing mindfulness
- Beginning simply and get progressively more difficult
- The first four: counting the breath, following the breath, placing, and analyzing
Four Establishments of Mindfulness 04: Breathing mindfulness (download)
Let’s start off with our motivation. Again, let’s generate an appreciation for the preciousness of this life and the incredible opportunity that we have to practice the Dharma, that most living beings don’t have—including most other human beings. They either have no access to the Dharma, no interest in the Dharma, or various other hindrances. So, our fortune is nothing to get arrogant or complacent about because it arose simply due to causes, and then once that causal energy is over, the results change as well. We’re not guaranteed to have this fortune forever, and for that reason, it’s important to continue to create the causes to meet the Dharma, study it, practice it, and so on.
It’s also important, with respect to our Dharma practice, that we’re not doing it just for our own benefit. We’re not just trying to get out of samsara because we’re fed up with it ourselves. But really feel connected to all other living beings and have a very sincere, heartfelt wish that they be happy. We’re not wishing them the mundane kind of happiness, but really the bliss and joy that comes through spiritual realizations. Let’s cultivate the aspiration to bring that about, and in order to bring it about, we have to become fully enlightened buddhas ourselves. That’s the bodhicitta motivation: to become a fully enlightened buddha for the benefit of all living beings. So, we’re going to listen to teachings tonight to learn how to practice the different kinds of mindfulness, because that is a practice that is very essential on the path to enlightenment.
Rejoicing in virtue
We’ve had a very full day today, don’t you think? With the ordination and so many guests coming, there was really so much happiness and real rejoicing. And here’s just a little anecdote about our plum tree: I walk by it every time on my way to and from the meditation hall. Yesterday, I passed it on my way in for the bhikshuni posada, our twice-monthly confession, and there were no plums on the ground. When I came out, I walked back past it and there were plums all over the place. It was like the tree was very pleased with the bhikshuni posada. And then the same thing happened today with the ordination. I walked there, the plums were all been gone, and I came back—and this was before the wind started—and there were lots of plums. So really, it was like the tree was celebrating as well, it was quite sweet.
We’re going to continue talking about mindfulness. Last week, I was talking about the preparatory practices to the Four Establishments of Mindfulness. Because there’s the preparatory practices and then the actual practice. Part of the preparatory practice was practicing mindfulness and also that other mental factor I spoke of, introspective awareness, in our daily life, in all of our activities. When we’re coming, when we’re going, when we’re standing and sitting, speaking, and everything else. It’s to be aware of what we’re doing, to be aware of how we’re doing it, to be aware if it’s an appropriate thing to be doing at that time and place and with those particular people around us. So, that’s a very all-encompassing practice, that goes on all day long no matter where we’re living or what else is going on in our lives. That’s part of the preparatory practice; it’s going to help us get going.
Six Kinds of Breathing Meditation
Then, there’s another aspect of the preparatory practice which constitutes some meditations on the breath. These meditations are from the Abhidharmakosha, the Treasury of Knowledge by Vasubandhu; there are six kind of breathing meditations. They’re also taught in the context of mindfulness of the body, because the breath is part of the body. But it seems they’re also spoken of as part of the preparatory practices because focusing on the breath can really help settle the mind and prepare it for more in-depth meditation. And as we were discussing before, when we do the Four Foundations of Mindfulness, we are doing them not so much for the development of serenity, although that comes, but specifically for the development of insight into understanding the real nature of reality, not just for developing concentration.
In these six types of breathing meditation, they start out kind of simple and then they get progressively more difficult. But they’re quite interesting and things that you might want to work with over some time.
Counting the breath
So, the first one is called “counting the breath.” You begin by relaxing your body and mind, and you’ll notice very often when I lead meditation, I start people off with a body relaxation, focusing and just feeling yourself sitting here, and being aware of the sensation in your feet and your legs and relaxing tension, being aware of sensations in your belly. Lots of people tighten up their belly without even being aware of it. So, we’re being aware of sensations in your belly, relaxing them. And we’re aware of sensations in your whole torso, because a lot of people put their stress in their shoulders, in the back, in their neck. Any of you do that? Yes? So, it’s learning how to relax that. I find one exercise very helpful, which is to lift your shoulders up as high as you can get them and kind of tuck your chin in, and then let your shoulders fall very hard. I find that very good for releasing tensions.
Then it’s also being mindful or aware of the sensations in your neck, your jaw, your facial muscles. Lots of people, their neck is tight; especially if you work at a computer, your neck is held at an odd angle. I find a lot of people, because of the glasses they wear, have neck pain because their glasses are bifocals, so to see somebody nearby they have to lift their chin like this. Have you noticed a lot of people doing that nowadays? They don’t talk to you straight but with their head lifted, and you think, “Oh, are they being a little bit arrogant?” No, it’s not that. It’s that they’re wearing glasses and they’re trying to see clearly. But it makes the whole neck and shoulders quite tight. Sometimes, we clench our jaw. We’re not even aware of it, so we make sure our jaw is relaxed and also our facial muscles. We have this whole thing about putting on a face, and we kind of do. Our muscles are tight in some way or another. So, I don’t know what, but if you’re aware of your face, you’ll find tight muscles or whatever, so it’s being aware of that and relaxing all those things in the body.
There are lots of things that could be going on in our body that provoke tension that we’re not even aware of. Some of them could be physical, depending on the work we do. A lot of us aren’t very tuned in to our body, so we don’t pick things up in a proper way; we don’t move in a proper way. Because we aren’t tuned into to what’s going on in our body, then, all of a sudden, things get out of whack and we don’t quite understand it. So, doing some yoga, some tai chi, qigong—something like that can be very helpful. And also, just getting regular exercise can help. I’ve really noticed that many people who come to the Abbey are not used to moving their bodies. Being here is a major stretch for them, and they’re like a third of my age. I’m feeling old, but people whose bodies should be much more active and healthy than mine, they’re kind of panting when I’m doing okay. We really need to keep our bodies healthy and not simply be couch potatoes.
And also, it’s important to tune into our body so that if some part of it is getting tense, we know how to discover that and then how to release it. And what we were talking about in the meditation hall this afternoon relates to that, too, because lots of times when you’re feeling different emotions, there are signals in your body going on beforehand. But if we’re not aware of our body, these signals completely miss us, and then we somehow, very suddenly, find ourselves in a state of rage or a state of incredible desire and attachment. And it’s because we’re really out of touch with our body and don’t know how to recognize the signals going on in our body and how our mental states relate to our body.
It can be something that’s very helpful, to tune into our body every once in a while. When you sit down to eat, in addition to offering your food, which slows down the process, check in with your body and see if your body is relaxed or if you’re tensed up. Do the same thing when you lie down to sleep. If you’re having trouble going to sleep, maybe your body is all tense and you’re not even recognizing it. It’s interesting just to tune into the body and let the muscles relax so that it kind of feels like your body is getting heavier, but what you’re doing is relaxing the muscles.
So, you start off by relaxing your body. And we usually think of relaxing as just lying down, sprawling, but you can sprawl, and your body can still be quite tense. It’s the same way that we usually think relaxing the mind means turning on a TV program, but I don’t think that’s going to relax our mind. It usually makes our mind tighter because of the emotions that the programs are trying to invoke in us. Don’t think that relaxing just means doing whatever because usually we get so confused, and we think mindfulness is, “Okay, I’d better be really mindful: what’s happening as I’m walking; what’s happening as I’m breathing.”
You’ll notice, with some people when they meditate, their eyebrows are all scrunched up: “I’ve got to be so mindful; I’ve got to really concentrate.” That’s not mindfulness; that’s tension. That’s pushing. That’s stress. We really need to watch out for that because actual mindfulness and awareness makes us more relaxed because we’re being more in tune. When we’re not in tune, that’s when we get confused, and we think that pushing means being mindful. Do any of you notice when you’re meditating that your brows are tensed up? It’s interesting to observe the faces people are making. That’s what I meant by making sure your facial muscles are relaxed.
You want to start out just checking in with your body, and then you want to breathe comfortably and let your breath be at an even speed and an even strength. At different times when you meditate, your natural breathing pattern will be different because the breath is very related to the mind. It’s related to the rest of the body, so what’s going on in your mind and your body is going to influence your breath. But at least try at the beginning to make sure that you’re breathing in a healthy way, and many of us don’t. A healthy way of breathing is that your diaphragm is moving when you’re inhaling and exhaling. An unhealthy way is that only our upper chest is breathing. A lot of us who are habitually stressed or who are addicted to adrenaline in our body, then we’re very used to having short breaths. When we have short breaths, it’s usually our upper chest that’s moving, not our belly.
When I’m talking about our belly moving, I’m not talking about taking deliberately deep breaths, because you don’t want to do that when you’re doing breathing meditation. Every once in a while, you’re in the hall and you hear somebody exhale loudly. You know the whole hall is silent and you’re trying to meditate, and you can’t focus on your own breath because somebody is entertaining you with the sound of their breath; we’re not talking about that. That shouldn’t be happening. We shouldn’t be making noise with our breath, unless of course you have allergies or some physical deformity, your breath should be smooth.
But try it for a minute. Put one hand on your belly and one hand on your upper chest. Now, examine how you regularly breathe and see what moves. Now breathe in such a way that your belly moves, so that your belly is going slightly out when you inhale and falling when you exhale. Is your upper chest moving then? No. Now take some breaths where your upper chest is moving. What’s the difference between the breaths that you take when your belly is moving and the breaths you take when your upper chest is moving?
Audience: [Inaudible]
Venerable Thubten Chodron (VTC): Yes, which ones are shallow?
Audience: Your chest.
VTC: It’s your chest, your upper chest. They’re short and they’re shallow, aren’t they? The breathing from your belly, you get more air in and it’s more relaxed, isn’t it? For some of us, at the beginning, it may feel strange because we’re so used to breathing from our upper chest, and if we’re just very used to getting these adrenaline rushes, we like to keep ourselves in a state of pumped-up energy. That affects our body in the long run and affects our breathing pattern.
You want to make sure that you’re breathing in a healthy way but, like I said, you’re not doing anything weird, like taking deliberate deep breaths from your belly and making lots of sound, not like that. Just try and be mindful, like noticing where you are breathing. And like I said, at different times when we sit down to meditate, our breathing pattern may be very different, so we don’t have to try to deliberately manipulate it, although sometimes we might try to slow it down a little bit. But we don’t even have to do that. Sometimes, just becoming mindful of how it is that we’re breathing, just that awareness of what’s going on in our body, that automatically helps to settle the breath down.
In this first meditation, it’s called “Counting the Breath.” Each cycle of out and in is counted as one. Notice I said one cycle is out and in; we usually think one breath is in and out. This is a different way of thinking of our breath. Out and in is one breath. So, at each breath, you count a number. They recommend that you go to ten, but you don’t go higher than ten because if you go higher than ten, you’re going to get really confused with all the numbers. 11,168. 11,169. You know? You’re going to get lost in the counting. So, just go to ten. They say don’t go less than ten, because if we do, our mind will get slack. We’ll space out pretty quick. It sounds very simple, but it’s not actually so easy to count to ten. Because we kind of get to one, and then we think about what we’re going to do tomorrow and we come back over and we start with one again. We may get to one and a half and then we think about what we did yesterday. And we come back again—it’s not always so easy. Or you find that you can count the numbers well, but you’re not really paying attention to each breath. You set one part of your mind on automatic for the counting and the other part of your mind goes traveling throughout the universe. Here you want to keep your attention on the breath and be quite aware that out and in is one, out and in is two.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Right now, we’re just on counting. I’m going to get to those kind in future meditations. Right now, we’re just on counting.
You can place your attention here at the nostrils and feel the breath as it goes in and out here if you want to, if that helps you. Some people like to focus their belly. Actually here, in this meditation, it doesn’t stress focusing at any particular place in your body; it’s rather just focusing on breathing and on counting the breath.
Again, don’t make your mind tight by counting too high and getting confused, and don’t let it get lax by not counting enough. Sometimes we mix up the numbers, and sometimes we forget what number we’re on. It just happened a second ago that we counted, but we can’t remember what number we’re on. Even though it’s a simple meditation, it’s not always so easy to do.
Proper meditation posture
Now, in terms of your posture, it’s good to sit cross-legged if you can. Of course, they recommend the full vajra if you can, which is your left on your right thigh, your right foot on your left thigh. If you can’t do that, then you can put your right foot down in front—this left one’s still on that thigh—or you can bring the left one down—that’s kind of how Tara sits. Or you can sit like how we sat in grade school—cross-legged. Or you can sit on a little bench, like they do in some of the Zen temples, or you can sit in a straight-backed chair.
Don’t sit in a chair where you lean back. But try and sit in one with a straight back and really focus on sitting up straight. If you’re in a chair, your feet should be flat on the floor; they shouldn’t be crossed. But if you don’t need to sit in a chair, don’t. Sit on the floor. Your head is level. You can tuck your chin in just a little bit, but it shouldn’t be tucked in completely. Don’t have your chin high, because that leads to distraction. Your head should be level. If anything, it’s going to be tucked in just a little bit. With your hands, the right is on the left, the thumbs are touching so it makes a triangle, and your hands are in your lap against your body. When you do that, then there’s automatically some space between the side of your body and the inside of your arms, and that allows for more circulation of the air.
This seating posture helps with the internal circulation of your internal winds. The eyes, lower them. They say sometimes to look at the tip of your nose, but I find that a little bewildering. Or you might look just at the space in front of you, but your eyes are just a little bit open, so you actually shouldn’t be looking at anything. The reason you keep your eyes open is to let some light in because when light comes in, you won’t be as drowsy. So, especially if you have problems with drowsiness, keep your eyes a little bit open. But your eyes should not be open to where you’re looking ahead like this, because then you’re going to start looking around to everything else and all the sensory stimuli is really going to be distracting. The head should be level, eyes open just a little bit to let some light in, but not really looking at anything, because you’re focusing inside, on your breath. You’re not focusing outside, on what’s going on in the room
Your back should be straight; that’s quite important. Some people are really slouched. Some people are subtly slouched. If you sit all slouched over and try to meditate, you’re going to have a lot of problems with drowsiness. It’s really important to sit up straight. You may need to do things to strengthen your stomach muscles and your back muscles so that you can sit up straight and keep your shoulders level, but they shouldn’t be slouched over like this. Some of us are so used to bad posture that we feel like we’re sitting up straight when we’re actually slouched a bit. Because this is how we usually sit, we’re not even aware that we can straighten our body more. Do any of you notice that about yourself?
As you’re doing the breathing, you’re really paying attention to each breath so as you’re exhaling, you’re aware, “Oh, I’m starting to exhale. I am exhaling. The exhalation is about to finish. It has finished.” It doesn’t mean that you’re giving yourself a sportscaster running report of the breath, with a lot of internal chatter in your mind. It just means that you’re being aware of these different stages of the breath: “Okay, I’m starting to exhale. It’s going on. I can feel that the breath is nearing going out. Now it has ended.” Then you become aware if there’s a pause between that out-breath and the next in-breath. When you start to breathe in, you become aware, “I’m starting to breathe in. I am breathing in. I’m about to finish breathing in. I am finished.” And then, similarly, be aware if there is a pause between that in-breath, which is completion of your first breath, and then the next out-breath. So, you’re aware of all these different stages.
Sometimes, at the beginning, if you’re not used to it, just becoming aware of out and in, out and in, is already enough. You might start with just the awareness of out and in and see if you can get to ten on that. As you get some success with that, then you become more aware of the different stages in the exhalation, the different stages in the inhalation. And then, that slows you down, or it slows your mind down in the sense that you have to focus in more detail, so there’s less chance for your mind to go traveling the universe. That’s what you do for counting the breath. That’s all the Abhidharmakosha says about it.
One of my teachers, when he taught it, he added some more, and he said if you concentrate well doing this, then you might reach a point where your thoughts kind of disappear, and you’re left just with the radiant nature of the mind. Or you might get into a place where your mind really settles down and then you can start watching the thoughts. And so, at that point it can be interesting to watch. Can you sense a thought before you think it? And where was that thought before it was in your mind? And where is it when you are thinking it? And when it stops, where did that thought go? Does the thought just vanish into nothing?
It gets you focused on, “What actually is a thought?” Because we’re thinking all day long, so much of the time we’re thinking. We’re not even aware that we’re thinking. We usually believe everything we think without examining if a thought is correct or incorrect. We just believe the content of our thought. And often, we’re not even aware we’re thinking. So, let alone understanding the content of our thought, we aren’t even aware of what a thought is. So, this is getting more advanced.
Like I said, this wasn’t included in the Abhidharmakosha part, but it can be an interesting thing just to be observant of. It’s not to get tight about it, like “Where’s that thought?” But it’s just to watch it. Because you know how sometimes we have these really weird thoughts that come out of nowhere? Yes? Everybody has pretty weird thoughts sometimes? It can be interesting to ask, “Where did that thought come from?” Did a thought exist somewhere else and then come into your mind? Before something arises, where is it? And after it ceases, where does it go? If you study Madhyamika philosophy, this can get really interesting.
So, that’s the first one called counting the breath.
Following the breath
The second one is called “Following the Breath.” Here again, you don’t deliberately slow it down, but your breath is slower because, hopefully, you’re more focused. When you inhale, you follow the breath in and you imagine after it goes through your nose, it goes to your throat, your heart, your navel, your thighs, the soles of your feet. And then when you exhale, it goes from the soles of your feet, up to your navel, your heart, your throat, and back out your nose. You’re aware of the breath flowing through your whole body. And when you do the exhalation part, because you’re also visualizing here in a way, you can think of the breath going out a short distance from your body. So, it’s not like it just stops here. If you’re not very strong, or your attention isn’t very strong, then just think the breath goes out a short distance and then it comes back in when you inhale. If you’re stronger, then you can send the breath out a little bit further in front of you and then it comes back in when you inhale. But you’re really seeing the breath go through your whole body.
Now, sometimes people can get confused: “Okay, I’m going down here and then, oh, my legs are crossed, so then does the air go out here, then it goes in here, to my sole, now I’m breathing out, so the air has to go out then it goes in, then it comes out.” We can get a little bit confused that way. I find it easier, when you’re doing this to just think of your body in a straight position. The breath comes in through the nostrils, goes straight down to the soles, comes right back up. You’re really feeling how the breath is moving through the body.
I’ve tried it a little bit. If I put my attention on the breath, and I have my attention going from here and then going down and then going up, it causes a lot of restlessness. Have you ever watched the snow fall, and you can either watch the snow fall in front of you, or you can take one snowflake and follow it down? And you know how it affects you differently when you do that? Some of you come back in the winter, you can try it. But when you’re following one snowflake down, it causes a lot of movement. So, when you’re doing this, don’t make the focus in your body move that quickly, because that can really feel uncomfortable. But rather, just see your body as a whole and feel the air as it goes. Well, first in an out-breath, it’s coming up and then going down. It’s running clear through your body and then out a little bit, a short distance, and then in again.
Again, you’re going to be breathing a little bit slower here because, if you’re doing fast breaths, there’s no chance for the air to move down to your feet. That’s the second one, called following the breath.
Placing the breath
The third one is called “Placing.” Here, you’re again focusing on the breath from the tip of the nose to the soles of your feet, but you’re thinking of the breath here as a very fine thread that is still and immovable. It could be a fine thread, like a very thin filigree of light even, something very thin that is running from your nostrils down to the soles of your feet. The breath is appearing in the form of this very subtle thread, and the thread is not moving.
The thread is not going up and down as you inhale and exhale. It’s not moving sideways; it’s not having waves and dancing and doing different things. It’s just very still and straight, and that’s your breath when you start an outbreath, as it goes up and out, as it goes in. So, you imagine that thread. Again, it’s a thread of light, don’t make it like a concrete post in the middle of your body. That’s not going to work; it’s going to be quite uncomfortable.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: You’re placing your attention on this thread. When you do these meditations, you do them in order because they start out simpler and then get harder, okay? So, the placing one, it’s like the previous one, going from the tip of your nose to the soles of your feet, but here it’s envisioned as that very fine thread that is very still, very subtle.
As you’re exhaling and inhaling, you’re aware of the different sensations along that thread. You can just be aware, “Is something hot? Is it cold? Is it comfortable or uncomfortable?” You’re becoming more aware of internal sensations in your body. Because we have a wind element—the Tibetans call it “lung,” the Chinese call it “chi,”—that flows through the body. It is linked with the very gross breath that comes into our nostrils, but it’s a much more kind of subtle breath. There’s that kind of breath movement going on in our body all the time. By starting to focus on the gross external breath, that’s going to help get us more in touch with the internal breath. And so, the different sensations along that thread of the breath is manifesting as that thread. So, that’s the third one called placing.
Analyzing the breath
Then, the fourth one is called “Analyzing.” So here, you’re looking at the breathing process. You’re not focusing so much on the out-breath and the in-breath as much as you are investigating the breathing process. One way to do it is to see that the breath isn’t just the wind element or the air element but that it has aspects of all four elements and also the derivatives of the elements. The four elements are earth, water, fire, and air.
Sometimes the breath can be heavy, which is a little bit of the earth element. The breath can be moist, which is a little bit of the water element. It can be hot or warm—fire element. And then the movement itself is the wind element. We know that the derivatives are color and smell, taste, and tactile sensation. Does the wind have color? Today, our air is kind of dusty brown. Maybe what we’re breathing in has that—the wind has stirred up all the dry dust. Sometimes the breath has a scent. Sometimes it can have a taste. It has a tactile sensation. So, you’re analyzing the breath here and really seeing the four elements, the four derivatives.
With this type, you’re getting more into “What is breath? What is this wind element?” And it can become very interesting because while an element is within our body, we feel like it’s me. But when the same element is outside of our body, it doesn’t feel like it’s me. When we inhale, the air is inside, and it goes in the package of what we call me. When that same air gets blown outside, it’s not me anymore. And then somebody else can actually inhale that same air, that same wind, that came out of our body. We begin to understand how our body is quite impermanent. When the breath is going in and out: here’s the wind element. It’s not completely me because I breathe it out, and when I breathe it out, somebody else breathes it in, and I’m breathing in the wind element that was in somebody else’s body. So, what’s somebody else’s body and what’s my body?
It doesn’t talk about this here, but I also find when you’re doing more of this kind of analytic meditation, it changes how we might see the hardness, the earth element. For example, let’s say there’s some broccoli growing in the garden. There’s broccoli. That’s the earth element, the hardness. That’s not me; that broccoli is not me. But it’s interesting how as soon as we put it in our mouth and chew it and it goes into our stomach, it’s kind of me, isn’t it? And then it actually gets changed and that same earth element goes in and nourishes all my cells, and then it’s really me, isn’t it? And some of it comes out as poop, the next day or the day after, and then that part is not me anymore. But while it’s in me, it feels like me, especially if you’re constipated. [laughter]
It gets quite interesting observing what I consider to be me, and what I consider not me. When I eat that broccoli and it’s breaking down and it’s going to nourish all my cells, is it me? Or is it my body? When we look at the broccoli out there, it doesn’t look like my body. But then it can change into my body. Or I just had a big blister, and the doctor drained it with a needle. When I looked at it, the blister, I felt like that’s my body, this big thing on my foot. When the doctor extracted all this fluid, then that’s not my body. But it’s the same stuff. It’s just very interesting. It gets us to think, “What do I consider me and what do I consider my body?” Because often, our image of our body is this thing that is just very solid, very intact, like our skin is some kind of impermeable box and nothing comes in, nothing goes out, and everything bound by this skin is me, this big, permanent me. Right?
So then, somebody comes and pokes me, and we think, “You’re touching me!” But if we had our hand amputated and the hand was sitting on the table and somebody touched it, we wouldn’t say, “You’re touching me.” It gets very interesting here. What do we consider me? What do we consider my body? Because my body doesn’t feel like it’s just a bunch of earth, water, fire, air, broccoli, spaghetti, and chocolate cake. It feels like it’s not just that, you know? There’s me in here—it’s me, or it’s mine. The me-ness, the my-ness, that’s much more evident to us than the broccoli and spaghetti.
When you look in the mirror at your face, do you think, “Oh, that’s broccoli and spaghetti transformed”? Do you think that? No. Is your face the transformation of broccoli and spaghetti? If you eat broccoli and spaghetti, it sure is. If you eat ham and eggs, then your face is a transformation of ham and eggs. But it’s true, isn’t it? You don’t look like you’re convinced. [laughter] We have this feeling about our body. If we look at just that reality of our body, that’s really what it is. But our gut feeling about our body is not that. Our gut feeling about this body is that it’s me or mine, or it’s made of some kind of magic material that’s unrelated to the cauliflower, and the cauliflower isn’t related to the dirt.
We don’t think of our body as a transformation of that soil. You know all the soil that you shoveled into the garden in the spring when we got the new soil? That soil is in our body now. That soil is me, if we say this body is me. But we don’t think, “I’m a bunch of dirt.” We think, “I’m beautiful.” We have some pretty strange notions, don’t we? So, we start really examining what is here, and it’s focusing on the breath in particular. I extrapolated to the body because I like doing that. I find that quite interesting. Something else I find interesting is when you’re eating in community, and you put some salad on your plate and the person next to you puts salad on their plate. The salad you eat is going to become your body that you become very attached to. The salad our friend next to us eats is going to become part of their body that we aren’t very attached to, at least not in the same way. We might be attached to them if they’re very good looking or something, but not in a sense of this being me or mine.
And yet, we could easily have switched plates of salad, couldn’t we? Yes? You eat my plate and I eat your plate, and then that becomes each of our bodies that we then feel are me or mine. But it’s just salad, and the salad could have been exchanged, and we could have been eating something else. So, that the salad we ate, why do we get so attached to it and call it me or my body when somebody else could have eaten it, and it would have been them and their body? When you examine things like this then you really begin to notice how we use the words “me” and “my” and what import those words have. And even though they’re just words, even though they’re just labels—wow—we imbue them with a whole lot more meaning.
It’s the same thing here with the air: what somebody else breathes out, I breathe in and then I think, “Oh, it’s my breath.” You sneeze, and you’re contaminating my breath. Because we have this idea that I’m going to breathe in this air that’s right here, and because I’m already set to breathe it in, it’s already mine. And then you sneezed and contaminated it. So, even though it’s still outside, you sneezed and you contaminated my breath. Or even if somebody didn’t sneeze, they just breathe out and there’s the virus or the bacteria in their breath, it’s, “Oh, you contaminated my breath.” But it’s actually their breath. It was in their body. So, are we stealing their breath? It gives us some insight on how we use the words “my” and “mine.”
Q & A
Okay so let’s stop here for questions.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: So, you’re not slouching, but you want to be able to sit without tension in your back.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Well, straight doesn’t mean you’re in the Army, not rigid, but straight should be able to be relaxed. But you need to strengthen your muscles there, too. If your muscles aren’t strong in your belly and your back, then it’s going to be very hard to sit up straight. And even if you’re sitting up straight, it’s going to feel like you’re in the Army, because you’re so used to slouching.
One thing they say is good is instead of feeling like you’re having to sit up straight from your back to feel instead that there is a little string pulling on your spine from your head. And if you feel like, “Oh okay, something’s pulling me up and straightening me,” then you’re not so tense when you straighten your body.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Yes, you can be thinking that you’re exhaling the carbon dioxide, and it’s going to nourish the plants, and they’re putting off oxygen which is going to nourish you. And that’s helpful for really seeing how interdependent we are.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Yes, you start all over if you get distracted. That’s why they say to see if you can even make it until ten.
Audience: How long do you spend on each part? What determines when you move on?
VTC: There’s a lot of flexibility here. You can stay with one meditation for a whole session; you can stay with one meditation for some weeks and months before moving onto the next one. Or if you want to, you can work with one of them for part of a session and then move on—if your mind is calmer—to the second one, and then move onto the third one. So, there are different ways of playing with it. If you’re really going to get some success with it, then it’s good to kind of master one before going onto the next. But like I said, sometimes it’s interesting just to do one after the other and see where you get.
Audience: When you’re doing this type of analysis of the breath and the body, I feel like one of the reasons that we cling to these ideas of I and mine is because the air or the broccoli or dirt becomes mixed with the form skanda, but when we imbibe it, we mix it with feeling and perception, and we have a much more direct conscious experience of it. That almost, to me, leads to some defensiveness about it: “Well, it is mine because now I’m conscious of it.”
VTC: So, there is this feeling that the broccoli becomes part of my body, and my body is linked to my consciousness, and I experience pain and pleasure and neutral feelings with this body, so now this broccoli or the transformation of the broccoli really is mine. You’re asking, isn’t that right, isn’t it mine? Isn’t there some reason to be defensive about it because this is mine, it’s not yours? One thing to watch and to really see is that how impermanent our body is and how everything in our body is getting recycled all the time. They say that all of our cells are rejuvenated and that in seven years we have an entire new set of cells. Even looking that way, what is there that’s some kind of stable me or some kind of stable body that’s worthy of being attached to?
And that question about well it’s linked with my consciousness, so now I feel pain or pleasure due to what’s happened to that broccoli, it’s funny, isn’t it, to think of your body like that? Like imagine this big heap of spaghetti and broccoli and ice cream and everything, just heaped in front of you and then, like a cartoon, it goes—whoop—and it becomes your body. But that’s kind of what happens, isn’t it? I mean it’s more through a physical process, but it’s just all that stuff piled up there and—whoop—you transform it and throw out a bunch of stuff as your pee and your poo, and that’s what remains. And then, of course, we’re sloughing cells off all the time, and everything in the body is changing. But notice how little we are aware of that. Every time we drink water and then pee, look at how much change is going on in our body, but we don’t feel like my body is changing. It just all feels so concrete, doesn’t it?
And then also, I find it very interesting that you brought up that it gets mixed with the four skandas in the sense that now this broccoli is causing us pain or pleasure. When this broccoli transforms into a hangnail, then it’s causing me pain. When this broccoli transforms into my skin and I pet a kitty, then the broccoli is bringing me pleasure. It’s very peculiar. And why am I so attached to the sensations of this particular body? What’s the relationship between the I and the body? Why do I even call it my body? Shantideva, in chapter eight of Guide to a Bodhisattva’s Way of Life, when he talks about exchanging self and others, he brings up this whole issue about why are we so attached to this body? Why not be as attached to somebody else’s body? And our answer is, “Well, because I feel what’s happening with this body.” And Shantideva says, “That’s nice, but that’s basically habit. Because your body is actually the sperm and blood of your parents and all the stuff you’ve eaten, so none of it is actually yours. So, why are you so attached to what’s happening to it?” It’s a good question.
Audience: So, if we’re actually able to analyze in this way, and we really start to eradicate that clinging to it, then do we become conscious of the bodies of others, like the internal experiences of others?
VTC: So, if we lessen the habit of clinging to our body, do we become aware of the internal physical experiences of others? Probably not instantly—I would assume if you have some kind of psychic power, you might. But you would still notice the physical sensations in your body, but there wouldn’t be so much reactivity to them. It would just be receognizing that there’s sensations. Right now, we feel some sensation and boy, not only do we feel it, but we make up some story about it: “I have a hangnail, and I have to give a talk for an hour, and it hurts. And I want to cut it off, but I can’t in the middle of this talk. And what are people going to think of me? And every time I touch it, it hurts.” You know? And it’s a hangnail, for goodness sake. You know how we get so attached to everything that our body experiences. To lessen that feeling of I and mine actually can give us a lot of freedom.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Somebody who has a good understanding of dependent arising, would they see the spaghetti and the broccoli? They would see kind of the change that happened—from earth, to spaghetti and broccoli, to body, to skin cells and the skin cells get sloughed off and get recycled in one way and dead cells get recycled in another way. And, actually, none of it is there to really consider me in the long run.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Yes, contemplate the science.
Audience: [Inaudible]
VTC: Well, it’s just the nature of something—something has a substantial cause in a continuity. The mind stream has a continuity that in that stream one moment of consciousness leads to another moment of consciousness. But it is true that as we go from one life to the next, you might have human mental aggregates in this life, and the mental aggregates of a deva in the next life, and the mental aggregates of an animal in the following life. Not only the body changes, but also the mental aggregates change. But what there is is that continuity of consciousness, of clarity and awareness?
Venerable Thubten Chodron
Venerable Chodron emphasizes the practical application of Buddha’s teachings in our daily lives and is especially skilled at explaining them in ways easily understood and practiced by Westerners. She is well known for her warm, humorous, and lucid teachings. She was ordained as a Buddhist nun in 1977 by Kyabje Ling Rinpoche in Dharamsala, India, and in 1986 she received bhikshuni (full) ordination in Taiwan. Read her full bio.

