The best learning
The best learning
Part of a series of teachings on a set of verses from the text Wisdom of the Kadam Masters.
- How the realization of no-self cuts the root of samsara
- Creating merit on the method side of the path
- Contemplating impermanence as a stepping stone to emptiness
Wisdom of the Kadam Masters: The best learning (download)
We’ll continue talking about the first line,
The best learning is realizing the truth of no self.
Why is that the best learning?
It’s interesting, here, learning means “realizing.” The best learning is realizing. It doesn’t say the best learning is memorizing all the points. Or the best learning is knowing how to say all the words without understanding them. He said the best learning is realizing.
Why is it realizing no-self? Because that is the only realization that actually cuts the root of cyclic existence. Bodhicitta, for example, and all of our other practices on the method side of the path are very, very important. That’s how we create merit. Without bodhicitta we can’t become a fully awakened buddha. But without the realization of emptiness we can’t cut the root of samsara. Bodhicitta cannot cut that root. Only the mind that directly cognizes the opposite of what ignorance cognizes is capable of cutting the root of the ignorance.
Ignorance grasps at inherent existence. This wisdom realizes the opposite of that, the absence, the emptiness of inherent existence.
It’s also one of the most difficult things to realize. Holiness says emptiness is more difficult to understand than bodhicitta, but bodhicitta is more difficult to realize, but that doesn’t mean that emptiness is a snap of the fingers, because if it were then we would have attained liberation a long time ago. It’s not so easy. It takes a lot of work and a lot of contemplation.
If you’re finding the teachings on emptiness difficult for you then start out contemplating impermanence. That’s a very good way to ease yourself into a better understanding of how thing exist, and from there it’s easier to get to emptiness.
With impermanence there’s gross impermanence, like sun rises, sun sets, and death. Those are gross impermanence. But here (we’re) really talking about subtle impermanence, the fact that things arise, abide, and cease in every split second. And actually, when you look at it, you can’t even find a split second. We have this image, sometimes we hear, one moment, second moment, third moment, as if they’re nice little discreet moments with some kind of glue holding them together so they form a continuity.
Actually, when you really sit there you can’t isolate one moment. You cannot find a moment, because whatever you pick, half of it’s gone already and half of it is yet to come. So where is that present moment? And yet, the present is the only time we ever live. It’s really kind of a puzzle when you get into it. But the more you get into that it can really help with understanding emptiness. When you think about subtle impermanence and the fact that things change moment to moment, they aren’t the same in the next moment, then automatically the questions comes, “Well then, what is it that goes from one moment to the next?” If they aren’t the same, and they aren’t the same through and through, then can you say that there’s an essence that goes from one moment to the next moment? That’s one way that kind of leads you into emptiness.
Another way that leads you into emptiness is when you get into subtle impermanence…. Why are things having that kind of subtle impermanence? Because they’re dependent on causes and conditions. That means that things don’t exist under their own power. They can’t support themselves because they’re completely dependent on causes and conditions that came before them. Something that is completely dependent on something else, again, cannot have its own inherent essence.
An inherent essence is just sitting there. That’s what this thing IS. I’m ME. Inherently. Sitting here. And that’s it. Not dependent on anything else. And that’s the way we feel. But the moment we start looking, and seeing “Do we really exist as an independent entity in any way, ” we being to see that any which way we look we’re completely dependent on other things. We’re dependent on our body, our mind. We’re dependent on our parents. We’re dependent on society. We’re dependent on this whole make-up. Everything around us conditions who we are, and we exist in relationship to it. We aren’t one single little ball in this whole sea of dependent things, and we’re this one thing that’s in the center that’s independent, and should be able to control the rest of the mess. Yes, like “That’s all dependent but I’m here and I should be able to control the rest of that mess.”
When you start to see, “Well actually no I’m not this little blob here….” And forget controlling anything. Just forget it. Then you get some feeling of how things change, they don’t have an inherent essence, like that.
Those are just some ways, in addition to studying the philosophy, but maybe some easier ways when you’re meditating to start to think about emptiness.
Lama (Yeshe) used to look at us and say, “Emptiness is not somewhere someplace far away in another universe. It’s right here, dear.” It’s your very nature, you just don’t see it. So not to think of emptiness as something in some other place that you have to go to.
That’s why I think it’s much better to say “ultimate truth” rather than “absolute truth.” “Absolute truth” gives you this idea of an absolute reality that’s independent of everything. “Ultimate” just means the deepest way of existing. It’s not some absolute somewhere, some place in another dimension that we have to get all weird about in order to realize. Lama would look at us and say, “It’s right here. Right here.”
[In response to audience] A continuum of a same type means that what appears from moment to moment looks like the thing that was there from the previous moment. This table, there’s a continuum of the same type because this table existed yesterday, and the table existed the day before, and so on. It just means that what you see from moment to moment looks kind of the same. But just because it looks the same doesn’t mean it is the same. That’s the point.
Venerable Thubten Chodron
Venerable Chodron emphasizes the practical application of Buddha’s teachings in our daily lives and is especially skilled at explaining them in ways easily understood and practiced by Westerners. She is well known for her warm, humorous, and lucid teachings. She was ordained as a Buddhist nun in 1977 by Kyabje Ling Rinpoche in Dharamsala, India, and in 1986 she received bhikshuni (full) ordination in Taiwan. Read her full bio.